When Coaching Crosses the Line: The Hidden Harm of Toxic Coaching in Youth Soccer

When Coaching Crosses the Line: The Hidden Harm of Toxic Coaching in Youth Soccer

We often celebrate the passionate coach on the sidelines when they are shouting instructions, demanding perfection, and pushing players to their limits. But what if that passion turns toxic? What if the sideline intensity we applaud is the very thing driving young athletes away from the game and damaging their mental health in the process?

Take a 15-year-old girl who once loved soccer now dreads practice. She’s constantly anxious. She second-guesses herself. She feels worthless if she’s not starting. Her identity has been reduced to the number of minutes played and the mistakes made. How does this happen, and what role do the coach and parent play in this? It is all down to culture.

According to a study in the Journal of Adolescent Health, athletes exposed to emotionally abusive environments were significantly more likely to report depressive symptoms and sport disengagement. This is a regular occurrence in youth soccer, yet many clubs continue to employ harmful methodologies. It is so widespread that the U.S. Center for SafeSport now includes emotional misconduct in its code of conduct and encourages education to prevent abuse in all forms.

It was encouraging to see Vince Ganzberg, a highly respected coach educator, advocate for wellness checks at a U.S. Soccer B License meeting. Vince is also a teacher, and his mindset reflects the type of growth-oriented leadership the game needs.

It’s vital to remember that every person we meet, child or adult, carries unseen burdens. We never know how close someone is to breaking. Choosing kindness costs nothing but means everything. Be strong enough to create the right culture for your kids.

Mental Health Matters More Than Medals

Adolescence is already a turbulent time of physical, emotional, and social change. Soccer can be a refuge, offering structure, identity, connection, and a sense of purpose. But in the wrong environment, it becomes a source of stress, fear, and self-doubt.

I’ve seen coaches so obsessed with winning that they made teenagers cry for losing a game 1-0. I’ve watched players who once loved the game withdraw from it entirely, crushed under the weight of unrealistic expectations and relentless criticism.

I once managed a coach who was visibly more invested in their "good" teams than in others. Their teams heard more criticism than instruction. The feedback from the sideline was mostly negative: "You're not working hard enough." "They want it more than you." It was always the players' fault.

This coach even kept the team’s trophies in their own office, separating them from the club’s shared achievements. Unsurprisingly, players reported feeling apprehensive about making mistakes. The environment was often tense. What resulted was that the team did not reach its full potential. It is a disappointing end for kids who did everything right but were let down by adults.

The Culture Problem

Why do coaches tie their identity to wins and losses? Many haven’t figured out who they are outside of soccer. The attention and praise they receive when winning can be intoxicating and addictive. When results dip, that praise dries up, and the cycle becomes desperate and erratic.

That’s when we see coaches yelling at 10-year-olds for trying something fun. That’s when fear replaces freedom. The joy is gone, replaced by anxiety.

Some parents adopt the "tough love" model, believing it promotes resilience. However, this begins to fracture team chemistry and erode trust. Coaches start to lean into that identity, the disciplinarian. And the kids suffer.

Coaches Must Grow Too

I often hear people say, "We weren’t afraid of hard work in our day." That may be true, but we were also raised in different times. Ask yourself: Who was your most successful coach, and why?

The best teams, even at the highest levels, have fun. Disciplinarian coaches may struggle to accept that. At many youth clubs, coaches push kids into "prestigious" leagues not for their development, but for their own ego. I did it myself when I was a younger coach. I wanted my teams to be something they are not. It was self-centered, and I wish I could have the time back.

What changed my perspective was studying psychology, specifically child development, learning theory, and emotional intelligence. Coaching licenses should begin with coursework in child psychology.

When kids are enjoying themselves, they thrive. Parents who buy into the disciplinarian method take a moment to consider your job. If your boss constantly criticizes you, do you perform well? Of course not. Why would it be any different for a 10-year-old?

We have 10-year-olds being assigned data analysis and match reports. Let kids be kids. Let them laugh, try new things, and make mistakes. That’s how growth happens.

What Really Matters

The weekend game should be about bragging rights, joy, and ice cream. The car ride home should be fun regardless of the score. Did your kid mess up? Laugh with them. Life is hard. Sharing some laughs with your kid can change both your days. Sport is a chance to make a positive difference in a kid’s life, not because they won a trophy, but because they got to spend time with people they like doing something they love, and they get to share that experience with their family, the people they trust. Removing that ease, that happiness from the equation also removes the safe space aspect of the sport, and there are already far too few safe spaces for kids in today’s society.

Soccer isn't just a game; it’s a memory-making machine. Don’t let your legacy make your child flinch when they look back. Make it something that hugs their heart.

Red Flags of a Toxic Coaching Culture

• Fear-Based Motivation: Players perform out of fear of being yelled at, benched, or publicly embarrassed.

• Emotional Manipulation: Coaches guilt players for mistakes or question their commitment when they’re injured or struggling.

• Lack of Psychological Safety: Players are afraid to ask questions, express their opinions, or make mistakes.

• No Room for Joy: The game becomes a source of stress rather than relief.

What Can Be Done?

• Clubs must implement coach education that includes mental health awareness, positive communication, and trauma-informed practices.

• Coaches should commit to growth, not just their players’, but their own. Reflective coaching and empathy matter more than tactical brilliance.

• Parents should ask: Is this environment helping my child thrive?

Reclaiming the Game

Soccer should be a safe space for expression, growth, and joy. Let’s stop excusing toxic behavior in the name of “competitiveness.” Let’s elevate coaching that builds character without breaking spirits.

Parent & Coach Checklist: Mentally Healthy Soccer Culture

• Do you praise effort over outcome?

• Are you checking in about how they feel, not just how they performed?

• Have you created a safe space for questions and mistakes?

• Are players enjoying the game and feeling ownership?

• Are you encouraging diverse sports experiences?

• Are you modeling emotional regulation on the sidelines?

• Have you asked yourself: Am I helping this child thrive in the long term?

#YouthSoccer #MentalHealth #CoachingMatters #PositiveCoaching #SoccerDevelopment #PlayerWellbeing #SafeSport #YouthDevelopment #SoccerParents #Leadership